By Susan Brink
Times Staff Writer
August 7, 2006
Before the antidepressant ever gets swallowed, before it dissolves and makes its way through the bloodstream and deep within the gray matter of the brain, some depressed patients start feeling better because they think they will. Experiments have shown that healing from depression starts in some people, called placebo responders, even when the drug given is just a sugar pill.
That, of course, is not enough to completely cure depression. But if a placebo can trick the brain into starting to get better, it's actually a pretty good predictor of who will continue to improve with antidepressant treatment.
A new study released last week in the American Journal of Psychiatry shows that the placebo effect may provide a head start for actual drug treatment by beginning to change the brain pathways that antidepressants will then follow.
The finding is an important step in helping scientists further refine who might be helped by drugs and what other factors might be involved in helping depressed patients get better.
The setting most likely matters too. Feeling free to talk openly about how he felt, along with a belief that he was going to be helped, set Chuck Park, 32, of Culver City on a path to healing. He was a participant in the 51-person study and one of 26 volunteers who received a placebo for the entire nine weeks of the trial. Another 25 volunteers received antidepressants for eight of the nine weeks. "After a few weeks, I started to feel a little better," he says. "The nurse, Michelle, would ask me how I was feeling, and I knew it wasn't just a superficial question. I could really tell her."
Activity measured by electroencephalogram in an area of the brain that is especially active in depressed patients, called the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, slows down in some people shortly after they begin getting a placebo. The slowdown is not enough to overcome depression, but those people whose brains responded to sugar pills ended up also responding to antidepressants in the new study. And Park, who improved slightly on a placebo, saw his depression lift completely after the trial ended and he started taking antidepressants.
"It's a very dramatic and clear example demonstrating that medication itself isn't the whole story," says Aimee M. Hunter, UCLA psychologist and lead author of the study. "If there is an actual formula or recipe for getting better, it may include medication, but it's very clear that it includes other factors or ingredients."
The placebo response, as the study measured it, appears to be a significant ingredient. Researchers attributed about 19% of the mood improvements measured on a depression scale after the trial to the placebo effect.
Psychiatric research is different from other kinds of medical research in that almost all depressed patients are given a placebo for about a week before the trial starts. Called the placebo lead-in, it is done to clear the body of other medications the patient might have been taking, but it is also done to get people used to filling out forms measuring their feelings and to allow them to meet the doctors and nurses who will be working with them. "Psychiatric studies are a lot more personal," says Dr. Andrew Leuchter, director of the laboratory of brain, behavior and pharmacology at UCLA.
"This is the first study to look at succession," Leuchter says. "There are brain changes due to placebo, and changes due to the medication."
But that still leaves 81% of the formula predicting treatment success yet to be sorted out. A patient's beliefs, hopes, expectations and relationship with the doctor might also play a role.
Leuchter is part of a team of researchers in 10 centers throughout the country who are beginning to further sort out the elements that go into treating depression. They will study 300 patients to see if they can use similar EEG testing to predict which patients will do well on specific antidepressants.
There are about 20 antidepressants available by prescription, and patients can fail on several before finding one that works. In fact, a National Institute of Mental Health sponsored study of 4,000 patients found that only about half of depressed patients got relief from their symptoms following a first round of treatment with either an antidepressant or talk therapy.
"Right now, trial and error is the rule, and it can take months to find the right medication," says Leuchter.
The new study he's involved with, called the Biomarkers for Rapid Identification of Treatment Effective in Major Depression trial, will look at brain changes following one week of treatment with any one of a number of antidepressants. That won't be enough time for the drugs to work clinically, but researchers will be looking for early brain changes. Volunteers will again be tested with EEGs after about three months of treatment. "We can look at early EEG changes to see if any of those changes predict how they did later," he says.
If early brain changes can alert physicians to patients who are on the right track for treatment, Leuchter says, it could cut down on the time needed to find the right drug for the right patient. "We're hoping that within three years, this might be a test available in doctors' offices," he says.
It's not just the right drug, either, that has yet to be sorted out. Depression is complicated and the NIMH is conducting a seven-year study, called the Sequenced Treatment Alternatives to Relieve Depression, to determine the effectiveness of various treatments, including drugs and psychotherapy and combinations of both.
"We know from other studies that psychotherapy also causes certain brain changes," Leuchter says. "I believe that engagement with physicians and attention is a form of supportive therapy."
It could be, he says, that just as drugs, placebo and talk therapy can change the brain's circuitry, so can wanting to get better, believing one will get better, or hearing a physician say there is great hope that you'll get better.
IN THE WORKPLACE
New Research on Depression in the Workplace.
For more information please click here
To subscribe to SADAG's newsletter, click here
Mental Health Matters Journal for Psychiatrists & GP's
Click here for more info on articles & how to subscribe
Literacy is a luxury that many of us take for granted. We depend on written communication for information, guidance, and access to heath care information That is why SADAG created SPEAKING BOOKS and revolutionized the way information is delivered to low literacy communities. It's exactly what it sounds like.a book that talks to the reader in his or her local language, delivering critical information in an interactive, and educational way.
The customizable 16-page book, accompanied by local celebrity audio recordings, ensures that vital health and social messages can be seen, heard, read and understood..
We started with books on Teen Suicide prevention , HIV, AIDS and Depression, Understanding Mental Health and have developed over 30 titles, such as TB, Malaria, Polio, Vaccines for over 30 countries.
- Click here to see speaking books in action
- Click here for sample book on clinical trials
- Click here for latest press release 1.
- Click here for latest press release 2.
- Click here to connect to international site www.booksofhope.com
- Speaking books for Health Care YouTube
Depressed Brain can be 'Primed'
By Susan Brink
Dr Reddy's Help Line
0800 21 22 23
Pharmadynamics Police &Trauma Line
0800 20 50 26
Adcock Ingram Depression and Anxiety Helpline
0800 70 80 90
Destiny Helpline for Youth & Students
0800 41 42 43
0800 55 44 33
Department of Social Development Substance Abuse Line 24hr helpline
0800 12 13 14
Suicide Crisis Line
0800 567 567
SADAG Mental Health Line
011 234 4837
Akeso Psychiatric Response Unit 24 Hour
0861 435 787
Cipla Mental Health Helpline
0800 456 789
MENTAL HEALTH CALENDAR 2018
Teen Suicide Prevention Week
11 - 18 February
Bipolar Awareness Day
Substance Abuse Awareness Day
Mental Health Awareness Month
1 – 31 July
Panic Awareness Day
World Suicide Prevention Day
World Mental Health Day
View our list of informative Infographs.
SADAG KZN Branch
SADAG have launched a new office in Durban with the support of Psychiatrist Dr Suvira Ramlall and Clinical Psychologist, Suntosh Pillay.
The offices are placed in St Joseph’s Hospital and are managed by Lyn Norton.
The KZN Branch is deeply committed to;
- Launching new Support Groups
- Workshops on aspects of Mental Health
- School Talks on Suicide Prevention
- Corporate Wellness For KZN companies
Please click here for more information about the KZN activities.
Want to become a volunteer counsellor? Contact Michelle/Christine 0800 21 22 23
Download Application Form Here
If you are interested in starting a Support Group, please contact Michelle on 0800 21 22 23.
To find a Support Group in your area, please phone SADAG on 0800 21 22 23.
If you are a journalist writing a story contact Cassey on
011 234 4837 /email@example.com